Why Choose Ohio Mutual Insurance

Small Town Values

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group traces its roots to 1901, when the Ohio Mutual, Tornado, Cyclone and Windstorm Insurance Association began providing insurance to property owners across Ohio. Today, with more than a century of success behind us, we retain our small town values while offering a broad array of industry-leading personal and commercial insurance products backed up by cutting-edge tools and resources.

Community Involvement

More than half of our associates live in our home county, and we believe that regular support of our community is the right thing to do. The company has a history of charitable giving, including contributing to United Way, participating in the American Cancer Society Relay for Life, and offering major gifts to local community organizations, schools, and regional economic development efforts.

We've also been there for community members by offering donations and financial support during times of need, including the historic flood in the Bucyrus area in 2007.

More than half of our associates live in our home county, and we believe that regular support of our community is the right thing to do.

Our Agents Choose Us

Our industry-leading insurance products are marketed through a carefully selected group of independent insurance agents. These agents are our most important business partners, and what's more, these agents choose us. Independent insurance agents counsel our policyholders about the best way to protect the things that are most valuable to them: their families, their homes, and their businesses. These agents have the ability to evaluate and recommend products from many different companies, and they frequently choose Ohio Mutual as the company that offers the best value, service, and protection for policyholders. The Ohio Insurance Agents Association recognized Ohio Mutual as its 2018 Eagle Award honoree, and in 2009 the nation's largest association of independent insurance agents honored Ohio Mutual with its National Company Award of Excellence.

Financial Strength

Our stable, experienced, and forward-thinking management team allows us to consistently outperform many of our competitors. Ohio Mutual Insurance Group writes more than $240 million in premiums each year, covering homes, autos, farms, and commercial properties in seven states. We maintain a prestigious "A" Excellent rating from AM Best, and were named among the top 50 insurers in the country by Ward Group from 2009 to 2013, recognizing our outstanding operating performance, capitalization, underwriting expertise, and prudent investment strategy.

What people are saying about Ohio Mutual insurance agents

Let us recommend the right independent insurance agent with the right coverage for you.